With Suffer Divine, Darkest Hour just released their best album since 2007
Updated: Nov 9

If there’s one thing I love, it’s American metalcore bands moonlighting as Swedish melodic death metal bands. A great example of this is just about anything Darkest Hour released from 2000 to 2011. Gothenburg af. Whether it’s An Epitaph from 2001’s So Sedated, So Secure or Sound The Surrender from 2005’s seminal Undoing Ruin, here is a band that know how to play with incredible, intricate lead work.
So here we are in 2026 and the band have gone and done it again with Suffer Divine. The title of the article says it all: This is the band’s full-on best work since 2007’s Deliver Us. Why do I feel it took almost 20 years for the band to nail it from front to back again? Well, Darkest Hour have an interesting history when it comes to the back half of their impressive catalog. Lineup changes that occurred with 2014’s self-titled record saw the band begin experimenting with more of a polished, groove-oriented sound. Having recruited a rhythm section more in line with the djent trend of the time and that record specifically eying a changing festival circuit landscape for an attempt at radio success were big changes from 2011’s safe but underwhelming The Human Romance. And while I actually appreciate the catchy, radio-ready songwriting of songs like The Misery We Make and By The Starlight, some Darkest Hour fans felt it a bridge too far removed from the band’s golden run up through 2009’s The Eternal Return. By the way, give that album a go again. It introduced lead guitarist Mike Carrigan AKA Lonestar, holds up surprisingly well and goes for the throat.

Speaking of a more aggressive album, 2017’s Godless Prophets & The Migrant Flora went the exact opposite route of the self-titled record. Dry production, more hardcore influence, thrash sections and the most cutting John Henry vocal performance to-date. Jumping from Sumerian Records to Southern Lord was definitely a hell of a transition and spoke volumes about what the band wanted to be known for: Shredding and kicking ass. I did always find the self-titled record a bit of an odd proposition. After all, Darkest Hour already knew how to write catchy material. There isn’t a guitar line on Undoing Ruin or Deliver Us that isn’t hummable. Godless Prophets didn’t care about any of that. It wasn’t catchy and it wasn’t trying to crossover to radio. It just plain RIPPED. Knife In The Safe Room led it off and you knew immediately this was not the same band you last heard in 2014. The album sounded like it was being performed in a desert with no water to be found for miles. Just listen to album closer Beneath It Sleeps. This band, who for all intents and purposes last sounded like they were sitting in the Sirius XM Studios with a self-assured few radio singles, now sounded like unhinged vagabonds roaming through a sandstorm. And I fucking loved it.
The prevailing reaction to Godless Prophets was that it was a return to form for Darkest Hour. On the contrary; I think it made them a different beast than they’d ever been. Before when I would think of touring partners for Darkest Hour, fellow melodic New Wave of American Heavy Metal bands like Trivium and Unearth came to mind. After Godless Prophets? I could see a tour with Weekend Nachos and Nails, easily. The band sounded MEAN and unchained. A lot of that could be attributed to Kurt Ballou of Converge producing the record, but I think Darkest Hour are capable of more than they let on. There’s the Gothenburg influence we know, sure. And the band came up in metalcore circles so we know there’s hardcore and punk influences as well. But Powerviolence? I didn’t see that coming from them. I also didn’t see the total 180 coming next.
Perpetual Terminal dropped as a lead single in November 2023 and was the band’s first new music since Lonestar departed the band in 2020. Nico Santora took his place on lead guitar and what followed was the title track of the band’s forthcoming 10th album, Perpetual Terminal. I didn’t know what to expect. I would have thought a more raw album was incoming, but couldn’t quite foresee how the Godless Prophets sound could get much more intense than it had already been. So, I should have seen the Amon Amarth-sounding harmonized leads that open Perpetual Terminal coming from a mile away. This giving way to a speedy set of verses and possibly the biggest melodic lead for a chorus the band have ever composed was a far cry from the beatdown that was Knife In A Safe Room. But I was totally here for it. I loved that the band were experimenting again. However, this is not at all close to what Perpetual Terminal ended up being. In fact, I found it to be one of their most hardcore-influenced records after the fact. Societal Bile, A Prayer To The Holy Death and New Utopian Dream all were heavier on the chugging and getting to the chorus than they were more filled with huge melodies. But for that, the title track, The Nihilist Undone and potentially the band’s best closing track, Goddess of War, Give Me Something To Die For, delivered.
Elsewhere, Mausoleum was a hazy, grungy ballad of sorts with vocalist John Henry returning to the singing he had first attempted on the self-titled record. So this was a diverse record rather than a focused assault like Godless Prophets or a boardroom mission statement like self-titled. And honestly, the record didn’t stick with me as much for that reason. I missed the beautiful, flashy lead work and it felt like most of the songs wanted to be here and gone, getting from verses to choruses with riffs that weren’t as memorable as the band were capable of. The band’s next move would wash all of this clean from my mind, however.
I do not say lightly that Suffer Divine is Darkest Hour returning to form. Here is an album that means business and is so tightly composed and focused, it can be held up to the band’s defining mid-2000s run of albums. The title track is a chunky circle pit-inciter played in a ripping Drop-C. Mike Schleibaum is an unsung hero of thrash guitar playing and this settles it. The solo is jaw-dropping in its immediate intensity and how John Henry ushers it in with a “I hope you pay, you fucking… PIIIIIG”. This furious track absolutely melted my face off on first listen and struck me as a much more refined combination of Godless Prophets’ aggression and Perpetual Terminal’s attempt at succinct song structuring. If Suffer Divine was 10 more tracks of this, I’d walk away happy. No problem. Instead, what Darkest Hour did was craft their most melodic, catchy, enthralling release that has their unmistakable signature all over it.
I need only point to the second single Warrior, a triumphant, huge melodic death metal track. This is one of the band’s best songs ever. Okay, cool. Well, how about an album that opens with nothing but a blood-curdling scream and demonic whispers over nothing but the droning of amps firing up? And immediately flying after that into Gods of Decay, the most So Sedated, So Secure sounding track the band have released since 2001? A masterful blend of The Black Dahlia Murder lead work, blasting drums and the sort of hardcore punk/thrash blend I hope for when the band plays fast. Oh man, we’re so back. And the album only gets better from here. No Conquered Hearts takes the huge melodic approach of Perpetual Terminal’s title track and combines it with the combination of speed and dancing verse leads found on Deliver Us. Salvation actually reminded me of Ascendancy-era Trivium with an anthemic main lead, the kind Corey Beaulieu and Matt Heafy would play in the middle of a solo.
Don’t think that Darkest Hour are just playing the hits here though. They’re actually making new hits. I’ve never heard a haunting, tortured lament from the band like Vile Angel before. Opening with the tolling of funeral bells, a twisted The Black Dahlia Murder-esque harmony leads into a ripping verse. While most Darkest Hour songs make me feel hopeful or as if I’ve been transported somewhere, I hear the hate in this track. “Give me back my life” implies time wasted on an undeserving person and a move towards healing from that wrongful ownership. There’s a good balance between opposition and inspiring perseverance on Suffer Divine. Warrior and Tribalist, the latter with a worldly guitar melody that would fit in on a Sepultura or Soulfly record, are powerful not because of anger but because of the determination that comes with feelings of anger. Tribalist speaks to survival in the face of existentialism, for instance.
The Unforgiving Hand is one such track that did strike right to my heart much like With A Thousand Words To Say But One off Undoing Ruin or Demon(s) from Deliver Us. It’s one of the softer moments on Suffer Divine but that doesn’t mean it’s not a truly affecting track. “When the walls close in around you, when you breathe your final breath, listen to those who came before you, those who conquered death”. Going from this into the assault of Tribalist, and especially Everyday Horrors which could very well have been on Godless Prophets, is the best kind of whiplash. To wrap this honest-to-goodness masterpiece up, is A Story of Redemption and it is just as impactful of a closer as Goddess of War, Give Me Something To Die For was on Perpetual Terminal. Listen, there’s no band that can play As Daylight Dies-era, Killswitch Engage-esque riffs and not get my thumbs up. I instantly hear an emotional resonance just through the playing of that style of riffing because of how well Killswitch have married fast playing with soulful vocal delivery.
I definitely felt like I heard Darkest Hour pour their all into Suffer Divine as a whole. This is the best produced and best sounding record of their careers, if I’m being honest. Everything cuts through clearly and with impact. Mark Lewis did a stellar job. I also found that this is the record that Travis Orbin really settles in as the best drummer Darkest Hour have had. He crushes it here. Both the guitar work is just incredible here. Nico Santora gets to show his chops more than he did on Perpetual Terminal. A great bluesy guitar solo kicks in halfway through the closing track to start the harmonized sending off of what amounted to the best Darkest Hour album I have heard in years. “This is a story of redemption, revolution of the self, liberation of the mind”. One could also say Darkest Hour as a band are a story of redemption. I hear their ownership over the trajectory of their long and earned careers, over the tight musicianship they continue to display and over a catalog that, frankly, hasn’t truly missed yet. Even when pulled in directions that didn’t end up suiting them for the long haul, Darkest Hour know how to get it right. Here is one of metal’s most consistent bands in fine damn form.








Comments