top of page

20 Years of Crisis - A Reflection

Alyse Small
Oct 26
7 min read

Updated: Oct 29


I have such a clear memory of watching Warped Wednesday on Fuse back in 2006. I remember that first time hearing the drum into on This Could Be Anywhere in the World. Christ, Dallas sounded like a fucking angel. The music video is a chaotic blend of flood and flames, the band grinding it out in driving rain that's getting deeper and deeper before they're submerged. Goddamn, what a song. I'm almost ashamed to say it, but I wouldn't fully understand how brilliant Alexisonfire really was for nearly two decades after that video was released.


All summer, when I wasn't working, I watched music videos. I watched the shows about making the music videos and the interview shows. I loved AP with the sampler CDs and constantly burned mixes with ridiculous titles. My entire world revolved around music in the summers. I don't know how I got so obsessed with that song, and subsequently Young Cardinals, but never took the time to seek out more. I think I just ended up so down the emo/screamo rabbit hole I missed out on so much incredible music until I was a whole ass adult. It took finding City and Colour in college and the release of Otherness for me to finally sit down and consume the entire, available Alexisonfire catalogue. (Death Letter released on my birthday in 2024 and what an absolute treat that was.) But when I came back to Crisis, I was really kind of glad I didn't come to it all until I was an adult. I feel like I got so much more out it that I would have as a teenager.


It's honestly hard sitting at the keyboard, listening to the album, and trying to find the words to express how it makes me feel. (This next bit is going to come off as a stream of consciousness, so buckle up.) I listen now and feel hopeful, connected to a wider belief maybe. I know now that there are so many who feel the same way as I do about the world and current state of affairs, who had similar upbringings and struggles. I know now that I'm never alone and that hope is other people. I wouldn't have felt that way as a teenager when the record was released, it would have only been the anger and desperation at the forefront of my mind. The urgency and panic. When I was younger, I knew a lot of people who were desperate to escape our tiny hometowns and find something bigger and better. It always felt like time was running out to make decisions that would affect the rest of our lives when we barely knew who we were as people yet. I also recall a deep anxiety of being completely out of control of any aspect of life. I feel like I watched my generation be sold this dream of a bright future and we saw it all go up in flames in real time. We're adults now and I still feel like a lot of us can't find our way in the world. Maybe certain tracks are popping into your head now if you're already familiar with the album. The frantic tempos, throat-ripping screams, and driving riffs all take me back to 2006 in my parents living room. The nostalgia is strong, but listening now, it's blindingly clear how relevant Crisis is twenty years on. I'm thirty-five now and I've had my share of fake friends. The place I grew up has the same problems it did in 2006. Hell, I even worked 4 years as a mail carrier where I literally had to deal with mailbox arson. There's war, genocides, fascism, widespread disease, hunger, climate change, fear, crisis. Some things never change I guess, but we can fight for a better future.


Louder than Life - Joseph Bemiller, 2026
Louder than Life - Joseph Bemiller, 2026

Crisis isn't just beautifully composed musically, the lyrics throw their own punches. I won't bore you by breaking it down with a song by song analysis or anything, I want you to listen to it for yourself and feel it for yourself. I think you'll find that it holds up incredibly well, lyrically speaking. These tracks have never lost relevance, which could be a good or bad thing, but what I'm getting at is that it's timeless because it's real, raw, and honest.


The first track gives you the message in the first damn line, "Alright, this is from our hearts. Sincerity over simple chords." It's a record that wears its skull heart on its sleeve from start to finish. They weren't just writing a commentary on the world we were growing up in, but also rebelling against a genre that didn't quite fit them. As a fan, I had that certain feeling of purgatory too for a long time. I never fully fit in to any one box. I wasn't a scene kit, not really a screamo kid, but didn't blend in with the hardcore kids either. I felt like I was always on the outside of everything with my face pressed against the glass. This record smashed that fucking window. The first two records are great, but Crisis plays out like the first fully realized version of the band and the sound they've carried ever since. It is unapologetically AoF. It reaches out a calloused hand to bend the ear to attention and holds on with a vice grip for the entire 41 minute run time.


In my eyes, this is a perfect record in every aspect. From the mixing to the song order, it is immaculate. It's heavy musically and emotionally with a living, beating heart in Jordan Hastings on drums and Chris Steele on bass. Dallas Green and Jordan Pettit strike a counterbalance vocally that I think was unmatched by any other band that was out there at the time, and probably still is. And listen, there is no voice like that of Wade MacNeil. With his undercurrent that sounds somewhere between a gravel pit and cigarette ashes, they're an unstoppable vocal powerhouse. If you were ever in band in school, you probably know about the sacred pyramid of sound. These men have perfected it on this record, but there is also a roiling, molten core right in the center of the structure that they only ever did once. Gared O'Donnell (Planes Mistaken for Stars).


The first time I heard him on You Burn First, it was a spiritual experience. It felt like I was getting into a fight I knew I'd lose. Every savage word out his mouth kicks your ass on that track. Do yourself a favor. Put in your favorite earbuds, and turn it up as loud as you can stand it. Just close your eyes, lay back, and listen to that. When that second verse hits, it hits like a fucking train. Then there's the added layer of the second vocal line and high, raw, primal screams. Incredible. Inject that shit into my fucking veins. His feature is exquisitely brutal. At track 6, it acts as the opposite of an intermission and more like a grenade going off. (Gared O'Donnell was a truly singular talent with an indescribable voice. If you never listened to Planes Mistaken for Stars, that's your homework after you leave here. Just start with their self titled and go in order.)


The violence of You Burn First being bookended by We are the Sound and We are the End is severed up in an order that just makes progressive sense. Both songs about the rebellion of disenfranchised youth, so fitting for the millennial generation. These three tracks race from desperation "They have no god, they have no voice. So what is this I see? There is nothing but anger burning inside of me.", to anger "Cover me if there's a fire, cause I want you to burn first", into rage and a call to arms "The hand of man is no match for our warless army. Please tell me that this is the end of the world (and we will strike with the arms of gods)." They really got it so unbelieveably right on this.


Louder than Life - Joseph Bemiller, 2026
Louder than Life - Joseph Bemiller, 2026

Another smart decision worth noting is Keep it on Wax back to back with To a Friend. One really feels like the antithesis of the other. They're so opposite in tone and attitude. "Times change, people change with them. Some people love to play the victim." vs "You shouldn't have to fight alone, it's nobody's battle but your own." One is a friendship that's over and the other is a friendship that might still be saved, I don't know, it's just another little piece of this record that sticks with me. Crisis is just one of those albums that has always been able to give voice to some of the feelings I don't really know how to put into words. I relate to every track in some way, whether it's a little or a lot. These two songs are ones that resonate the most.


I know I called this "A Reflection," but really, it's a rambling love letter. I love this record, it gets me and the era I was brought up in. I love this band. This year, I was able to catch them, front and center during Louisville, KY's Louder than Life. I still can't believe I got to be on the rail for that. I of course had on a white button up and black and white plaid school skirt in homage to the self titled album cover. It was amazing, everything I wanted or could have hoped it would be. It was a shorter set, but they played the bangers.


Sweet Dreams of Otherness

Boiled Frogs

San Soleil

Dog's Blood

This Could be Anywhere in the World

Young Cardinals


I very eagerly await the next record. The teasers on Instagram from the studio were killing me, but the small glimpse you could get sounded great. Wade mentioned last month we might be seeing the first track in November and I hope that's accurate. You can expect a full review as soon as I can get my hands on it.


This is our celebration, come join the lost souls. Walk with us.


Louder than Life - Joseph Bemiller, 2026
Louder than Life - Joseph Bemiller, 2026

Comments


  • White YouTube Icon
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Twitter Icon
  • White Instagram Icon

© 2035 by ENERGY FLASH. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page