top of page

REVIEW: Wayfarer's Riders of the Setting Sun is a High Plains Fever Dream

Alyse Small
2 hours ago
7 min read

Indulge me here for a minute and imagine...


With hell they come.

With hell they come.

Lo come the horsemen, to bring round the end.


It's impossibly hot, you're losing sweat far more quickly than you can replace it. You know if you're thirsty, your horse is worse off for carrying you. It's been a long, long road coming across the Oklahoma panhandle into Colorado. Denver seems like nothing more than a mirage, something made up to focus your mind on to survive the monotony of the high plains. You've left a lot behind you, a lot of pain, but you're your own master now. Everything that comes next is entirely up to you. Your survival is entirely in your own hands. You wonder if death might not be the reprieve you're looking for. Finally on the horizon, there's a shimmer of a town. You thought it was just another trick of the eye, but it's been there the last couple miles and seems to be approaching. At last, relief from the summer's furnace. A stable and water for your horse, a cold beer, maybe a woman if the town is large enough for such an establishment. A real bed. There were a great many miles between you and the last one. Wouldn't it be such sweet bliss to lay your head down, even just for a few hours? As you approach the town, the hair starts to stand up on your arms and the back of your neck. It's too quiet, there's no sound of a poorly tuned saloon piano plinking out some old ragtime tune. No sound of people in the streets, or wagons, or anything. Your heart sinks a little, but even a ghost town will have a full well in these parts and maybe at least one mattressed bed. You come to the edge of town from upwind, it explains why there was no smell. The cause of the now oppressive silence, is death. Everywhere. Men, women, children, mules, even a chicken, all dead. Every corpse, man and animal, lined up in neat rows in the middle of town. The heavy smell is a mixture of sulfur and sweet, metallic notes of what must be gallons of blood splashed across the single street. You realize you've begun to tremble, and your horse responds by snorting and pawing at the dirt beneath you. You know she'll go no further and cross whatever imaginary line marks the town line. You don't want her to. What in the hell happened here? What kind of man, or men, would murder an entire town? You call out a single time in case there may be a survivor holed up somewhere safe. A horse responds and moves into the street from a near alley. A horse so black that its coat seems to swallow everything around it. A tall, hooded rider with .45s in belts crisscrossed at the hips. You suddenly feel cold as ice, panic knotting up deep in your guts. The figure raises its hands to push back the hood to reveal a thin and pallid face. The features are too sharp, the eyes like a rattlesnake's. For a few long seconds, you stare at each other from across the way before the stranger slowly tips a hat that is not there. A shiver runs up your spine from hind to scalp, but you force yourself to do the same. What did that poet say? "Cast a cold eye on life, on death. Horseman, pass by." Maybe not too far ahead there will be a homestead, there's nothing for you here.



Alyse's Two Cents




When I listen to Riders of the Setting Sun, my mind is immediately filled with ghost towns, outlaws, shootouts, and death. While not a far departure from their previous album, American Gothic, this one feels very different. Wayfarer has expertly crafted a sprawling soundscape of rich, layered vocals, reverberating melody, and the western metal sound we've come to know and love but Riders of the Setting Sun drags along in a way its predecessor did not. If American Gothic was the gunfight, this record is the aftermath. There's no crazy riffs or thrumming kick pedals. Listening back through their discography, there's actually nothing else that sounds quite like Riders. Their discography seems to not just be an evolution of their sound, but the evolution of a fully formed story as well, spanning just over a decade of music. Take a look at the names of the records and song titles and I think you'll see what I'm saying. I get the feeling that we're seeing a much wider tale being told, starting with Children of the Iron Age. It's like moving through the history of the west, starting from the first homosapiens, into the First Nations with Old Souls, the arrival and war between the first Europeans and Indigenous peoples in World's Blood, the settling of the west and advent of the railroad in A Romance with Violence, oil strikes and ranching with American Gothic, and finally the despair after the violence in Riders of the Setting Sun and what comes next. This I think is by far the gloomiest, and I mean all of this in the best possible way. I ADORE this album and I'm so excited for people to hear it. It's an atmospheric beauty. I low key hope their next record is about the Dust Bowl.


This is another band I had never heard of before getting review access and I have to say that within the first few seconds of The Dusklands, Wayfarer was immediately solidified as one of my favorite metal artists of any sub-genre right next to Amenra and this really might be my favorite piece in their body of work (because of course I went back and listened to everything). It's dark, moody, and brought to mind spaghetti western soundtracks, The Doors' Riders on the Storm, Red Dead Redemption, Stephen King's character Roland Deschain, Chris Isaak, Cormac McCarthy, Old Gods of Appalachia, and traditional murder ballads. I think my favorite track on the record has got to be Hollow Hearts on the Trail to Eden. When it hits the 3:30 mark it just goes absolutely crazy and becomes this wide open, otherworldly epic. I just can't get over how gorgeous it is.


There are some features on this record worth mentioning too. We see spots from David Eugene Edwards (16 Horsepower, Wovenhand), Munly J Munly and Rebecca Vera, Kelly Schilling, and Midwife. While they each lend their own flavor, that last is probably my favorite of the three. Madeline Johnston's ethereal voice to start the last track just makes sense. When Shane McCarthy's voice comes echoing in, it's a ghostly ensemble fitting for the end of the album. It's gives this vibe of a duet between an angel and a devil. Then there's a different kind of collab when it comes to the album art. Looks familiar doesn't it? It should, this was one of the final works of the legendary Tony Stella, who's art you'll recognize most likely from George Lucas movie posters. They couldn't have chosen a better man to encapsulate the feeling of the album.


Overall, this was another one with no skips. I could listen to Riders of the Setting Sun over and over again just for the vibes alone. Really, this is a great record with a lot of really wonderful technical and emotional work. It's rare that I listen to something and can so easily imagine a story being told and I honestly feel that way with each album. Wayfarer have truly honed their storytelling skills into sharp relief and I cannot wait for what comes next from them.


Manon Hure
Manon Hure


Matthew’s musing:


When it comes to Wayfarer, I was already along for the galloping ride and shouting “Giddy-up!”. Since 2020’s A Romance With Violence and especially since 2023’s American Gothic, I couldn’t wait to see what the band’s forward-thinking blend of black metal and Western folk/Americana would sound like. Well, I couldn’t have possibly seen, even as a mirage, the dust-blown, dreamy and massive sound of Riders of The Setting Sun. Just as much a gothic country western as it is a hazy rock album, I’ll not bury the lead here — This is one of the coolest records not only of 2026, but also one of the most ambitious records that I have heard in my 13 year album-reviewing career. By the end of the roughly 37 minute journey, I indeed felt like I had been through the desert on a horse with no name.


Manon Hure
Manon Hure

On my first listen of Riders of The Setting Sun, I didn’t know what to say. The departure from black metal on this album initially took me a moment to adjust to. I actually went back to study American Gothic and found that the telegraph to this clean vocal-driven sound was there all along in a track like Reaper On The Oilfields. The move to an entirely clean sound would be surprising enough on its own, but how about enlisting a production and mixing team that combined have worked with Beach House (James Barone) and Chelsea Wolfe (Ben Chisholm)? The results are gorgeous and bring in sounds I wouldn’t have expected from Wayfarer such as shoegaze and post-punk.


I won’t lead you entirely down the dusty trail here, but I will point at some of the landmarks that Riders of The Setting Sun has to offer. Perdition’s Crossing , which features another Colorado gothic Americana musician by the name of David Eugene Edwards, sneaks in dark, second-wave black metal chords to round out its otherwise folksy Western sound. Black Roses & Early Graves sounds like walking through a cemetery at midnight with the ghost of a rival gunslinger tugging at your ankles. It gave me, of all things, Darkwave vibes. Grey Country brings in another fellow Colorado goth country pale horseman, Munly J Munly, for one of the riffier mid-tempo tracks. His higher voice blends well with frontman Shane McCarthy’s low, cool droning. Munly’s bandmate Rebecca Vera also adds keys to this stellar track, making the sound even fuller.


I’ll leave you with the two most showstopping tracks on the record, its last two songs. Hollow Hearts On The Trail To Eden has a masterful build-up from atmospheric to a release of bright, melodic guitar soloing. Lastly, Prairies of Babylon goes full-on shoegaze, with vocals settled in the background while the song drenches you in its orange sun glow. If you are looking for an unexpectedly adventurous listen, I highly recommend Riders of The Setting Sun. Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to continue riding off into the sunset to one of 2026’s biggest surprises.



Comments


  • White YouTube Icon
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Twitter Icon
  • White Instagram Icon

© 2035 by ENERGY FLASH. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page