Whalefall: The Most Dangerous Prey *Spoilers*
Updated: Nov 9

I'll be straight up with you, when I first started seeing teasers and initial reactions for Whalefall, I had zero desire to see it. Honestly, I thought it looked silly and was actively making jokes about the "Whale eats a guy" movie. I was sold on Austin Abrams though, having loved both his most recent roles for Zach Cregger in Weapons and Resident Evil. This film made me eat my words through my own tears. Don't judge Whalefall until you give it a chance, I think it'll surprise you.
Content warning: Depiction of suicide.
Whalefall opens on Mitt Gardiner (Josh Brolin) laying on his back coughing and wheezing. A wider shot shows that he's on a boat with another man, Hewey (John Ortiz), who's fishing. This man does not move and does not initially react. The way he sits there reminded me of an aside or a tableau you might see in a stage play where all the background characters hold a pose while the main character becomes the sole focus framed by paused action. Mitt calmly gets up, kneels by a cooler, and opens it. He examines a handful of sealed letters, and removes a diving weight belt. He fastens it on, and moves to the edge of the deck. This is the first time the other man makes a move, and he begins to cry. Mitt casually steps off the side and into the water.
A hell of an opening scene right? When I first started seeing press for Whalefall, I really never planned on seeing it. Like I said, I haven't read the novel and just didn't have much interest in seeing some sort of real life Jonah or Pinocchio kind of situation play out, but then I saw someone mention online that it was more about grief than the whale so I wanted to give it a shot. What can I say, I love a metaphor. It's being marketed as a survival thriller, which it absolutely is, but I feel like that's a bit of a cop out after seeing it. This film is about a hell of a lot more than getting swallowed by a whale and with the first scene, Brian Duffield and Daniel Kraus send you on an emotional roller coaster that doesn't let up until the credits roll.

It's blindingly clear from the start that Mitt and his son Jay (Austin Abrams) have a strained relationship. Jay declines to visit his dad's empty grave and flashbacks throughout the film show their arguments and Mitt's domineering and abrasive personality up against Jay's more reserved and sensitive nature. The whole exposition are these interactions Jay has with people who knew and loved his dad, and they all have nothing but good things to say about him, but Jay wears his discomfort on his face. It's easy to see, even before you're shown any memories of their relationship that the man Mitt was as Jay's dad was wildly different from the version of him others knew. But even through all the struggle, Jay's whole reason for going on a solo dive in the first place is to find his father's remains to bring closure to his mom and sisters. The love is there, but so is a lot of pain. He doesn't even read the letter his dad left for him until the end when the whole ordeal is over and he goes out on a boat with his family to the location Mitt went for his last dive.
Author and co-writer Daniel Kraus didn't waste time getting to the point with the screenplay, but through the film you see all these puzzle pieces coming together to show you a fuller picture; it's a portrait of a complicated, messy kind of grief and loss. There's two stories being told simultaneously woven together by the whale, once you see it, I think you'll know what I mean by that. There's one particular there that I don't want to give away. There's the present survival horror situation of Jay's near death experience then another shown through memories of Jay's relationship with his dad, his dad's struggle and treatment for mesothelioma, and ultimate suicide. Sprinkled in all that is the information Jay needs to get out of the whale alive and come to terms with his grief. The survival story happens chronologically, but the secondary plot is like a red thread jumping through time, tying everything else together. In the New York City Comic Con panel, Daniel Kraus said something that I think really encapsulates the overall theme of the film and I'm sure the novel as well. In regards to death, and what a whale fall actually is and creates in the ocean ecosystem, he said, "They die, but their life radiates out from their death for generations." If you're not actually familiar with the term (they do explain it in the film),when a whale dies and sinks to the sea floor, it becomes a major source of food and during decomposition many species colonize in and around the area, sometimes for years, creating entire new ecosystems. Mitt chooses this for his own remains, to go back into the sea and create new life through his death. But in a less literal sense, a person's death ripples out through the lives of everyone that knew them. The people closest are affected the most and the effects of the loss travel outward changing everything in its path.
Having lost more than a few people to suicide, Whalefall really got to me. I started asking myself a lot of questions about dignity in death, how I've processed my own grief of those losses, and wondering what it will be like for me when I lose some of the people in my life that I have tumultuous relationships with. I think those are ideas and feelings that everyone can relate to in their own lives, I mean, everyone will experience intense grief at some point. A lot of feelings came up watching this that I was thinking about for a long time after I left the theater. It was even cathartic in a way.

There were some really great technical bits in Whalefall as well that are absolutely worth talking about. First, Daniel Kraus' dedication to scientific accuracy is admirable. In the NYC Comic Con panel he goes into a little more detail about how he talked to whale researchers and how in depth he went to get the details right. It's not quite 40 minutes and posted to Youtube if you're interested. I think the effort put into the facts plays a big part in making Whalefall special. While it seems totally bonkers, and although your chances of being gulped down by one of the largest mammals on earth are astronomically slim, they are not zero. Just ask Michael Packard, who was briefly caught in the mouth of a humpback whale in 2021. Now, would Jay survive a full hour in a sperm whale in real life? Those chances are pretty much zero, but we suspend disbelief there for the sake of entertainment. Like I said, this movie isn't really about the whale anyway.
The practical effects in Whalefall really knock it out of the park, largely thanks to the ever incredible Weta Workshop. They fabricated the squid, smaller sea life, the whale's interactive organs and mouth, and the 360 whale stomach sets where they filmed scenes in chronological order. The bioluminescence, was created first with club soda and a blacklight, and got beefed up in post via CGI. The sound waves you see towards the end of the film where the whale is calling out for help and any blood was also largely practical, created first with chemicals in a cloud tank and enchanted via CGI where needed. And finally, the part that really really got me. The heartbeat of the whale is a recording of Josh Brolin's heart. They were going to use a recording of an actual whale's heart, but it turns out that kind of thing is exceedingly rare, if one even exists at all. It ended up working out perfectly. I think knowing that little tidbit will make a big emotional difference for me when I rewatch it, as if I wasn't already crying through the end of the movie anyway. Brian Duffield mentioned in an interview with Collider, "It needs to feel more like he's inside of a god than inside of a monster-" and I think they really delivered. The soundtrack on this and sound design is also really great. I loved the music and how it helped to carry and convey the emotion of the film.
All in all, I'm so glad I went to see this and gave it a chance. I really enjoyed it and absolutely recommend it. Right now there's no date for the digital release, but we'll likely see it come out in late November or early December with it heading to Hulu in January or February. I wasn't able to find anything about a physical relase at the time of publishing this article, but I'll update it once I have some definite release dates.
Rotten Tomatoes - 74% / 81%
Letterboxd - 3.2






Comments